

Randolph "Randy" Bradley is a fast food worker in rural Louisiana who is slated to be promoted to manager, yet still submits to bullying by coworkers Chris and Jess. Benson sees Randy being bullied and he attempts to intervene; after being threatened by Chris to not interfere, Benson then goes to his car to retrieve a double-barrelled shotgun and kills everyone in the building save for Randy. Randy reluctantly helps Benson clean the bloody scene, they place the bodies in the freezer, and they close the restaurant early. The duo drive to a nearby diner, where Randy asks why Benson committed the shooting spree. Benson's response is to insult their waitress, saying that she hasn’t done anything remarkable in her life; Benson explains that he sees potential in Randy as someone who can achieve more, and says he thinks Randy is "fixable". Benson takes Randy to Benson's mother's house to give her some food and cigarettes. When Randy goes to get a phone for his disabled mother upon her request, Benson pins Randy against the wall and rebukes his mother. They return to Benson's car, where Benson says that he has to hurt Randy to make him learn and sets up a rule that he does only what is necessary for Randy. With Benson set on curing Randy of his indecisiveness, they head to a mall to talk to Randy’s ex-girlfriend, Lisa, at her workplace, because Randy never fully understood why his last relationship ended. Lisa explains that their breakup was due to Randy's apathy. At the parking lot, Randy then explains to Benson why his mother had him repeat second grade due to an incident with his former teacher, Mrs. Beard, in which he flung an eraser into her eye in anger after feeling mistreated by her, and how it ruined both their lives: Mrs. Beard eventually lost her eye and was mocked by students and faculty for her disfigurement; and Randy ended up suppressing his feelings throughout his life since then, due to the traumatic memory of his emotions harming others. Randy's submissive behavior is further shown by a brief phone call he has with his mother, who Benson concludes micromanages Randy after listening in.